Most Active Stories
Mon August 11, 2014
Two Ways President Obama Could Act On Immigration
Originally published on Mon August 11, 2014 8:51 pm
Sometime before the end of summer, President Obama is expected to take executive action to address the nation's broken immigration system.
The president's decision has in some ways been years in the making. It is built on his own action two years ago to defer deportation for so-called Dreamers — young people brought to the country illegally as children. And it is built on congressional failure to pass a sweeping immigration overhaul, a DREAM act or even an emergency funding measure to deal with all the unaccompanied children arriving at the border.
At a press conference last week, Obama sounded ready to act on his own.
"I promise you the American people don't want me just standing around twiddling my thumbs and waiting for Congress to get something done," he said.
The Department of Homeland Security Secretary is currently preparing a menu of options to present to the president as advocates and critics position themselves to respond. Here are two actions legal experts and advocates say the president could take:
Deferred Action Beyond The Dreamers
The president could direct the Department of Homeland Security to expand on the program for Dreamers, giving other groups of people a temporary reprieve from deportation and even issuing them work permits. A group of former government immigration attorneys described it in a 2011 memo.
"The executive branch, through the Secretary of Homeland Security, can exercise discretion not to prosecute a case by granting 'deferred action' to an otherwise removable (colloquially referred
to as 'deportable') immigrant. ...
"Deferred action does not confer any specific status on the individual and can be terminated at any time pursuant to the agency's discretion. DHS regulations, however, do permit deferred action recipients to be granted employment authorization.
"Deferred action determinations are made on a case-by-case basis, but eligibility for such discretionary relief can be extended to individuals based on their membership in a discrete class. For example, in June 2009, the Secretary of DHS granted deferred action to individuals who fell in to the following class: widows of U.S. citizens who were unable to adjust their status due to a
statutory restriction (related to duration of marriage at time of sponsor's death)."
This is the authority the Obama administration used in 2013 to created the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program for the Dreamers. Some 600,000 people have taken advantage of that program so far.
Congressman Luis Gutierrez, D-Ill., says he thinks the president will expand on the program, with the goal of keeping families together. That would mean giving temporary status to the undocumented parents of children born in the U.S.
"I think he says to himself, there are nearly five million American citizen children who have one or both parents that are undocumented," says Gutierrez. "You know what, I am going to let those parents raise those kids."
Parole In Place
Here's how it was described in leaked memo from staff at the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to its director, Alejandro Mayorkas:
"Granting parole to aliens in the US who have not been admitted or paroled is commonly referred to as 'parole in place' (PIP). By granting PIP, USCIS can eliminate the need for qualified recipients to return to their home country for consular processing, particularly when doing so might trigger a bar to returning."
This could be used to give relief to the spouses of American citizens who currently would have to leave the country for up to a decade before being allowed to re-enter the U.S. legally.
That's actually an idea Rep. Raul Labrador, R-Idaho, suggested in talks earlier this year. Labrador was an immigration attorney for 15 years.
"They are all ideas that we can go through the legislative process and get done and some of them might be good ideas," says Labrador.
In these cases, President Obama would be calling on immigration authorities to use prosecutorial discretion. Labrador argues that has to be done on a case-by-case basis and not broadly, for whole categories of people.
Even if President Obama does have the authority to go it alone on immigration, Labrador argues it would be a mistake. He says it would make relations even worse with the GOP-controlled House of Representatives, which has already voted to sue the president over the use of executive authority.
"He's going to poison the well," says Labrador. "He's going to make it impossible for us to do immigration reform with him and the most unfortunate thing is it's not going to be a permanent fix. It's going to be a fix that only lasts until the end of his term."
It's true: Anything the president does through executive authority could easily be reversed by the next president. That's one reason Obama had been reluctant to go this route.
But when it comes to the legal question, President Obama has a lot of legal precedent on his side, says Paul Virtue, a partner at the law firm Mayer Brown and a former U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service general counsel.
"The actions that I've heard being discussed are consistent with the court cases and the decisions on prosecutorial discretion," says Virtue.
He says the real question isn't one of legal authority, but rather policy and politics.
"The issue is much more fraught politically than it is legally," says Doris Meissner, a senior fellow at the Migration Policy Institute and former commissioner of the INS.
She says there are some limits on executive action.
"The president cannot give people green cards," says Meissner. "The president cannot give people citizenship. But as to temporary programs that protect people from deportation, those are the issues that are in play."
MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:
This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Melissa Block.
ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:
And I'm Robert Seigel. The Homeland Security Secretary is looking at ways President Obama can act on immigration on his own. A menu of possible executive actions is being prepared and President Obama is expected to act by the end of summer. NPR White House correspondent Tamara Keith reports on what the president can do.
TAMARA KEITH, BYLINE: President Obama's decision, expected within weeks, in some ways has been years in the making. It is built on his own action two years ago to defer deportation for so-called Dreamers - those are young people brought to the country illegally as children - and it is built on congressional failure. To pass a sweeping immigration overhaul, a dream act or even an emergency funding measure to deal with all the unaccompanied children arriving at the border. So says the president...
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: I'm going to have to make choices. That's what I was elected to do.
KEITH: At a press conference last week, the president sounded ready to act on his own.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
OBAMA: I promised you, the American people don't want me just standing around, twiddling my thumbs and waiting for Congress to get something done.
KEITH: One person who wants him to act boldly is Congressman Luis Gutierrez, a Democrat representing Chicago.
CONGRESSMAN LUIS GUTIERREZ: I believe the president is going to act in a broad manner and when I say that, I don't mean to sensationalize, but that means millions of people.
KEITH: He thinks the president will expand on the program for Dreamers, with the goal of keeping families together. So that might mean giving temporary status to the undocumented parents of children born in the U.S.
GUTIERREZ: And I think he says to himself look, there nearly 5 million American citizen children who have one or both parents that are undocumented and you know what, I going to let those parents raise those kids.
KEITH: He also thinks Obama is likely to give relief to the spouses of American citizens who currently would have to leave the country for up to a decade before being allowed to reenter the U.S. legally. That idea was suggested by Congressman Raul Labrador, a Republican from Idaho who is part of failed talks to pass an immigration overhaul in the house.
CONGRESSMAN RAUL LABRADOR: They're all ideas that we can go to the legislative process and get done, and some of them might be good ideas.
KEITH: Labrador says if Obama acts on his own, it would only make matters worse in the House, which is already suing the president over his use of executive power.
LABRADOR: He's going to poison the well, he's going to make it impossible for us to do immigration reform with him and the most unfortunate thing is that it's not going to be a permanent fix. It's going to be a fix that only lasts until the end of his term.
KEITH: But Paul Virtue says there's a long history of immigration authorities using prosecutorial discretion - setting priorities for who to deport. He's a partner at the law firm of Mayor Brown and a former U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service general council.
PAUL VIRTUE: The actions that I've hear being discussed are consistent with the court cases and the decisions on prosecutorial discretion.
KEITH: Virtue says the real question isn't legal authority - it's a matter of policy and politics. Doris Meisnner agrees.
DORIS MEISNNER: The issue is much more fraught politically that it is legally.
KEITH: Meisnner is a senior fellow at the Migration Policy Institute and former commissioner of the INS. She says there are some limits on executive action.
MEISNNER: The president cannot give people green cards. The president cannot give people citizenship. But as to temporary programs that protect people from deportation - those are the issues that are in play.
KEITH: Advocates are urging the president to go big, arguing that resistance will be fierce whatever he does. But the president must also consider how any action he takes will play in states where Democrats already face tough reelection odds this fall. Tamara Keith, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
Around the Nation