Current Weather
The Spy FM

Supreme Court Backs Secret Service Agents In Dick Cheney Case

Filed by KOSU News in US News.
June 4, 2012

In a case involving then-Vice President Dick Cheney’s Secret Service detail, the Supreme Court ruled Monday that agents accused of a politically motivated arrest are immune from suit. But the court’s unanimous ruling did little more than resolve this particular case.

The decision stems from an incident in 2006 in the Colorado resort town of Beaver Creek, where Cheney was shaking hands at a shopping mall. Steven Howards, upon seeing Cheney, got in line, and when his turn came he told the vice president that the Bush administration’s Iraq policies were “disgusting.”

Accounts differ as to what happened next. Howards and some Secret Service agents say he lightly patted Cheney on the shoulder. But other agents say the pat was more in the nature of a “forceful push.”

Nonetheless, when agents first approached Howards and asked him if he had touched the vice president, he said “no,” he hadn’t. On the basis of that denial, he was arrested for lying to federal agents and assaulting the vice president. The matter was quickly resolved after the charges were dropped and Howards conceded that, upon reflection, he had in fact patted Cheney on the shoulder, meaning “no harm.”

Howards, however, did not let the incident die. He filed a lawsuit contending that the Secret Service had arrested him in retaliation for the expression of his political views, and that the whole business of his alleged lie was an after-the-fact justification. The 10thU.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that even if the arrest was arguably valid, Howards’ First Amendment claim of retaliation should be decided by a jury trial.

The agents appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. They argued that they were entitled to a “qualified immunity” that shields government agents from lawsuits when the right they are accused of violating had not been “clearly established” at the time of the alleged violation.

The agents claimed that, even if they had violated Howards’ First Amendment rights by arresting him – which, to be sure, they vigorously denied – that right had not been clearly articulated by the Supreme Court. As a result, they should be immune from suit.

The court, in an 8-0 vote, agreed. Justice Elena Kagan did not take part in the ruling.

In a narrow opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the law on retaliatory arrest was too vague to hold the Secret Service agents liable. “This Court has never recognized a First Amendment right to be free from a retaliatory arrest” in circumstances like these, where arguably the arrest for lying to a federal agent was valid, wrote Thomas.

Although the court’s decision rested on the lack of clarity around the law on retaliatory arrests, the justices did nothing to settle that question. The court instead relied on the existing confusion to say that, whatever the law is — and they’re not telling — it wasn’t sufficiently unclear to the Secret Service agents at the time of Howards’ arrest. As a result, the agents are entitled to qualified immunity from suit.

Whether future law enforcement officials may be held accountable for allegedly politically-motivated arrests remains unclear and unresolved. [Copyright 2012 National Public Radio]

Leave a Reply

11AM to 12PM The Story

The Story

The Story with Dick Gordon brings the news home through first-person accounts. The live weekday program is passionate, personal, immediate and relevant to listeners, focusing on the news where it changes our lives, causes us to stop and rethink, inspires us.

Listen Live Now!

12PM to 1PM Fresh Air

Fresh Air

This one-hour program features Terry Gross' in-depth interviews with prominent cultural and entertainment figures, as well as distinguished experts on current affairs and news.

View the program guide!

1PM to 2PM Talk of the Nation

Talk of the Nation

Journalist Neal Conan leads a productive exchange of ideas and opinions on the issues that dominate the news landscape.

View the program guide!

Upcoming Events in your area (Submit your event today!)

Streaming audio and podcasts

Stream KOSU on your smartphone

Phone Streaming

SmartPhone listening options on this page are intended for many iPhones, Blackberries, etc. with low-cost software applications available to listen to our full-time web streams, both News on KOSU-1 and Classical on KOSU-2.

Learn more about our complete range of streaming services

We're perfecting the patient experience - Stillwater Medical Center