Current Weather
The Spy FM

Ex-Clinton Solicitor General, Colorado AG React To SCOTUS Arguments

Filed by KOSU News in US News.
March 27, 2012

It was a question that seemed to be one of the most difficult for the current solicitor general, Donald Verilli, to answer persuasively, at least to the obvious satisfaction of the conservative justices: If the individual mandate for the purchase of health insurance was found constitutional, what would limit Congress from passing other laws requiring people to buy products from broccoli to cell phones?

Walter Dellinger, who served as solicitor general during the Clinton administration and supports the Affordable Care Act, seemed to have no problem with that one during an appearance on All Things Considered Tuesday with John Suthers, Colorado’s attorney general, an opponent of the law whose state part of a lawsuit against it.

When ATC co-host Robert Siegel’s put the bright-line question to Dellinger, the lawyer said:

“Sure. I don’t think that’s a hard question. Because the issue is whether the power to regulate commerce includes the power to require commerce. And the government’s position is that you can require commerce on the part of people who are going to be inevitably engaged in the commerce for health care. When they do that they transfer the cost to others and it undermines the regulatory regime. That to me is a perfectly good limiting principle.”

Perhaps the conservative justices would have been impressed by Dellinger’s answer. Perhaps not. But he certainly delivered it with supreme confidence.

For his part, Suthers suggested to Robert there really could be no persuasive answer because the fundamental problem was that the federal government has no constitutional power to impose such mandates although states do.

SUTHERS: “This case has been about federalism from the beginning for the AGs. And the fact of the matter is, states are not burdened with enumerated powers that the federal government is. And under their police power, they probably can require people to buy insurance. Whether it’s good public policy or not is another question.”

As for Tuesday’s oral arguments, Suthers was clearly encouraged by what he heard while Dellinger seemed seemed genuinely unsure which way the court would ultimately go. He agreed that his pro-ACA side got grilled more than the opposing side, especially the court’s conservatives.

SUTHERS: “I think myself and my attorney general colleagues are heartened. We filed this case two years ago last week. Took a lot of criticism. A lot of the legal community, constitutional law professors, said it was not a well-founded case. We were asking very fundamental questions. And today in the courtroom, we heard the justices zeroing in on those very questions.”

DELLINGER: “I agree with John that more hostile questions were asked of the government overall than were asked of the challengers. But I came away from the argument not knowing what the outcome will be.

“And that’s because I think that Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kennedy, who sort of seemed to be in the balance of power, seemed genuinely troubled by aspects of each sides case. Obviously, they wanted to know what the government’s limiting principle was. But I think they were concerned on the challengers’ side that if you don’t have this incentive for people to have insurance, and make it part of this insurance reform that uses the private market, is the only option going to be to have a single-payer, national, monolithic system?”

[Copyright 2012 National Public Radio]

Leave a Reply

12AM to 5AM The Spy

The Spy

An eclectic mix of the Spy's library of more than 10,000 songs curated by Ferris O'Brien.

Listen Live Now!

5AM to 9AM Morning Edition

Morning Edition

For more than two decades, NPR's Morning Edition has prepared listeners for the day ahead with two hours of up-to-the-minute news, background analysis, commentary, and coverage of arts and sports.

View the program guide!

9AM to 10AM The Takeaway

The Takeaway

A fresh alternative in morning news, "The Takeaway" provides a breadth and depth of world, national and regional news coverage that is unprecedented in public media.

View the program guide!

Upcoming Events in your area (Submit your event today!)

Streaming audio and podcasts

Stream KOSU on your smartphone

Phone Streaming

SmartPhone listening options on this page are intended for many iPhones, Blackberries, etc. with low-cost software applications available to listen to our full-time web streams, both News on KOSU-1 and Classical on KOSU-2.

Learn more about our complete range of streaming services

We're perfecting the patient experience - Stillwater Medical Center