‘Matterhorn’ Author On What It’s Like ‘To Go To War’
Filed by KOSU News in Art & Life.
August 30, 2011
As a Marine during the Vietnam War, Karl Marlantes learned to fire an M16, to command a platoon, to fight and to kill. And in the four decades since Vietnam, he’s spent his time reading, reflecting and writing a memoir that has helped him come to terms with that experience.
In his book, What It Is Like To Go To War, Marlantes writes that while the Marine Corps trained him to kill, “it didn’t teach me how to deal with killing.”
Marlantes tells NPR’s Neal Conan about his experience in combat; the guilt, regret and shame, but also the eerie thrill, the challenges of coming home and what the U.S. could do to better prepare combat troops for war.
On what he remembers most from combat
“It was a particular kid that I killed up front and personal … It was in combat, and he was trying to kill us with hand grenades and a rifle. What it was is that [many years later] I saw some terrified kid. He was no longer the enemy, as we love to pseudospeciate. Because we have to. I mean… if you’re raised as a decent human being, killing somebody is against every moral thing you’ve ever been taught. And so, generally, in combat it’s krauts, the gooks, the yanks — whatever you want to do to try and make it so that it’s not a human being.
“But in this particular instance, I had him in my sights. And he turned and looked at me, and he could see — I was only about 10 feet way from him — that if I pulled the trigger, he was dead. And he had a hand grenade in his hands and I remember thinking to myself, ‘Don’t throw it, don’t throw it. I won’t pull the trigger.’
“And he threw it, and I pulled the trigger. But it was looking at his eyes that I realized he’s just a kid, like me. Another human being. He was born in North Vietnam; I was born in Oregon; we ended up on opposite sides of this terrible act that’s going on.”
On how he suppressed the shock of killing for decades
“At the time you’re very busy; you’re on adrenaline; people are trying to kill you. So you don’t tend to think about it. You’re also young.
“But by the time you start to get middle-aged, and this image just keeps coming back, I think that that’s when the psyche is saying, ‘You need to pay attention to this, and try to understand what went on.’ And I think that was kind of … a touchstone for me, to remind myself to try to come to terms with it in a mature and reasonable way …
“When I came back I just repressed it. I’d talk to my friends and we’d say, ‘Hey, what’s all this stuff about nightmares? You have nightmares? I don’t have nightmares. Well, it’s all B.S.’
“Well, 10 years after that conversation, I’m rolling around sweating at night, having nightmares and scaring my wife to death. Because you can’t repress it without bad consequences.”
On why soldiers need spiritual preparation for war
“It’s a difficult issue, but where I come down is, if you think about mystical experiences, they have certain things in common. One is that the mystic is always trying to be in the present. The mystic is always aware of his own mortality, right over his shoulder. They get into a position where they value other people’s lives over their own. In other words, their ego needs are subdued. And they’re a member of a larger group …
“Every one of those things happens in combat, every one of them. And whether it’s a mystical experience or an equivalent psychological state, I’m not prepared to say. But what I am arguing is that you have a 19-year-old experiencing something at that level, and then you have him come back and flip burgers at McDonalds without any help … or any preparation that this is going to happen to you and when it does, you’re going to feel like this and other people will feel the same way. And in some ways, that will help people come to terms with what I call a wound to the soul, as well as just a wound to the body or the brain.”
On what can be done to better prepare young soldiers for combat
“First of all, you’re dealing with generally very young people — 19, 18 years old. The odds of them being conscious even outside of combat are very low. But if you can tell somebody ahead of time, I think they’ll notice it when it happens…
“When you’re in the fight you’re not going to be conscious. You’re going to be at a basic … reptilian level. I mean, you are fighting for survival and you’re trying to kill somebody else. But the sooner that you can come back to become conscious of what you’ve done, I believe that the healing process that’s going to take place when you come back home is going to be sped up…
“If you can start the process — and I think it’s quite possible to start it right there immediately after a battle, when you’re finally safe — you can take time to reflect. Not only [reflect] on your own friends who have been killed — and you do need to take that time — but also reflect on the fact that these other people that you just killed were there sort of just by the grace of God or circumstances and you took their lives too and there’s no sense of being guilty about it. It was just part of the situation that both of you got thrown into. And luckily enough, you’re the one that came out alive. But to be able to bring it to consciousness sooner will help heal this terrible wound to our own souls faster.”
[Copyright 2011 National Public Radio]